Pavement people would have you believe that the density at a paving seam should be no more than 2% lower than the density of the lane on either side of it. If it falls below that, cracking and raveling will almost certainly occur. Raveling happens when the asphalt surface begins to break apart because small aggregate and binder detach from the pavement, and this process can quickly cause further deterioration. One study of asphalt joints, in fact, refers to the joint between two paving operations as often being the weakest part of the pavement.
We’re a paving contractor with The Pavement Group in Wexford, PA. We look at seam cracks in apartment lots across the Pittsburgh region every year. Most managers see a crack and blame the winter. In my experience, the crack started on paving day, and winter only finished the job.
What a Paving Seam Is, and Why It Fails First
A longitudinal seam is the joint between two parallel asphalt mats. The paver lays the first lane, and the second lane butts up against it. The first lane has a free edge, which is unsupported. When the roller goes over that edge, the material is forced to move sideways rather than be compacted. The edge ends up less dense than the rest of the lane. Lower density at the seam means there are more tiny air spaces within the asphalt, which lets water get in more easily. Once water is inside, it can freeze and expand, causing the seam to crack sooner and making the pavement deteriorate faster.
Low density means more air voids. A porous seam will allow water in. Minnesota pavement engineer puts it the less dense the joint, the more porous it is going to be. Water then does the rest of the damage.
Why Apartment Communities See This More Often
Apartment lots don’t pave like highways. You often see crews paving an occupied community in stages so the residents have access to their parking. That means you end up with a number of seams, and some of those seams will be hours or days older than their neighbors when the second pass is finally laid. Drive aisles, parking rows, and the approaches to the dumpsters all divide the lot up into narrow strips, so the seams end up in the wheel paths where the tires are going to be pounding them every day. Because of this, it’s important for managers to regularly monitor seams in high-risk areas like wheel paths and near dumpsters, as these spots are especially prone to early cracking.
Pennsylvania has tested these joints in the field. Test sections were constructed on I-79 in PA to compare the different construction techniques, and it was found that the technique makes a difference in the quality of the joint. Joint quality is a function of the technique, and the technique varies from crew to crew.
The Six Causes We See Most
The table below lists the causes in the order that we check them on site.
| Cause | What happens at the seam | Where the crack shows up |
| Low density at the unconfined edge | The roller pushes the first lane’s edge sideways | A crack or ravel line a few inches inside the first-paved lane |
| Cooled mat before the second pass | The cold edge bonds poorly, and research lists temperature loss during rolling as a cause | A thin gap exactly on the seam line |
| Height difference between lanes | One lane sits higher, so tires and blades hit the lip | Chipped, crumbling edge along the high side |
| Differential settlement | The base or a utility trench settles on one side | One side drops, and the crack widens over time |
| Weak bond at the joint face | The two mats never fuse, and one test used a rubberized asphalt tack coat on the unconfined edge to improve bonding | A straight, tight crack that opens each winter |
| Water and freeze-thaw cycling | Water freezes and expands by about 9 percent | Widening cracks, raveling, and eventual potholes |
Water is the one thing that really deserves a look in Western PA. Freeze-thaw damage is the worst, where you have days or weeks of temperature cycling around freezing (that’s the weather we have in most of our late winter). The plows then come along and rip right at the weakened edges. We looked at that second stage in How can Apartment Communities prevent pavement damage from snowplow operations?
Read the Crack Before You Call Anyone
The position of the crack tells you what the problem is. Use that table on your next walk around the property.
| Where the crack runs | Likely cause | What it tells us |
| Several inches inside the first-paved lane, parallel to the seam | Low density at the unconfined edge | The crew did not compact the edge well. Pavement research puts low-density zones at the outer edge of the first lane’s taper |
| Exactly on the seam, with a hairline gap | Cold joint or weak bond | The two lanes never fused |
| On the seam, with one side lower | Settlement or a height difference | Look for a utility trench or soft base nearby |
| Both sides of the seam, with raveling and dark staining | Water infiltration | Water has already reached the layers below |
| Seam lifts in late winter, then drops | Frost heave and thaw weakening | Water sits under the pavement or in the subgrade |
Five Facts to Gather About Your Lot’s History
Before you go and say a seam has failed due to bad paving, gather the history. Take those answers with you to any contractor you’ve got walking.
- The year you last paved or overlaid the lot and which contractor did the work
- Whether the crew paved in phases around resident parking
- Where utility crews cut trenches near the seam
- Where the lot drains, and where water collects along the seam during rain
- Whether a plow, a gate, or heavy trucks regularly cross the seam
Gate lanes add their own stress. We explain that pattern in How Should Property Managers Handle Asphalt Damage Around Apartment Parking Lot Gates?
Why We Diagnose Before We Quote
The Pavement Group has a national contractor network based out of Wexford, PA, and our contractor listing covers asphalt repair, paving and overlays, ADA work and concrete repair. On every apartment property, we trace every seam crack back to its root cause. A crack due to low edge density is going to require a different solution than a crack due to a failing base. Once you know the cause, you can then spend your repair budget once.
Every manager should outline some basic diagnosis steps before deciding on repairs. Start by walking the lot and looking for where cracks appear. Check if they run right along a seam, if the edges are starting to ravel, or if water appears to pool in those areas. Ask your contractor to measure seam density and compare it to the main mat, check the condition of the base under any problem spots, look for signs of drainage issues, and note where heavy vehicles or snowplows repeatedly cross seams. Make sure to gather information about previous repairs or overlays in those areas. Bringing these facts to a contractor will help you have more informed discussions and get the right solution for each crack.
Address Asphalt Cracking Before It Spreads
Cracks along apartment parking lot paving seams can develop from poor joint compaction, water infiltration, temperature changes, and heavy vehicle traffic. If left untreated, these weak points can allow further pavement deterioration and lead to more extensive repairs. The Pavement Group provides professional asphalt maintenance and repair solutions to help property managers protect their parking areas and extend pavement life. Contact our team to discuss your apartment community’s pavement needs.
Contact Us TodayFrequently Asked Questions
Should Apartment Managers Seal or Fill Cracks Along Paving Seams?
Seam cracks move with the temperature, so we seal them rather than fill them. Sealing involves routing a clean reservoir along the crack, blowing it dry, and then placing a rubberized sealant that will stretch and contract with the pavement. Filling involves the use of a cheaper material that is poured into a crack that is no longer going to move, and that approach fails on a seam that opens up every winter. The pavement preservation guidance is to use narrow crack sealing with rubberized asphalt on longitudinal cracks, and we do that. When the crack gets too wide, or the edge starts to ravel, we cut out the damaged strip and patch it with a new hot mix.
When Is the Best Time to Repair Seam Cracks in Western Pennsylvania?
We seal the seam cracks on dry days (when the pavement is frost-free and the crack is clean). Moisture will, of course, ruin the bond, and a Scottish road authority points out that the existing pavement has to be dry for most of the asphalt mixtures to bond. That makes early fall the best window in the Pittsburgh area, as the cracks have opened up during the summer heat and the weather stays dry. We also do a spring seal in once the ground has thawed and the surface is dry. If a crack opens up in the middle of winter, we put in a temporary repair and come back in the warmer months for the proper fix.
How Can Managers Tell Whether a Seam Crack Is Cosmetic or Structural?
Look at the width, the edge condition, and the movement. A very fine crack with tight, clean edges and no height difference across it is likely to be purely cosmetic and will seal up quite well. A crack wider than about a quarter of an inch with crumbling edges, one side lower than the other, or a network of cracks all connected will be indicative of a base or drainage problem. Pavement engineers will list longitudinal cracks, depressions, and raveling as the precursors to potholes and will point out that the main cause of potholes is delay in repair. We’ll press a probe into the crack and check for any soft or wet material, which will tell us whether the crack will seal or whether the base itself needs to be repaired.
How Do I Check Seam Quality on a New Paving Job Before the Warranty Ends?
Write a joint density requirement into the paving contract, as a number of agencies will specifically exclude the joint area from any density checks, and your contractor may well do the same. Kansas, for instance, requires a joint density of at least 91.0% of the theoretical maximum density or a difference of no more than 3.0 lbs/cu ft from the interior of the mat as per the Kansas joint density study. Ask the contractor to core or test the seam at a number of locations and provide you with the results in writing. Walk the lot after the first winter and after each winter during the warranty period and take a photo of any crack that occurs along a seam with the date. Get those photos to the contractor straight away, as a warranty claim is best made whilst the crack is still narrow.
Will a New Asphalt Overlay Stop Seam Cracks From Coming Back?
A plain overlay won’t stop them as the cracks in the old surface will propagate up through the new layer (that’s what they call reflective cracking in the industry). The movement at the old seam continues, and so the new asphalt will crack along the same line again, often within a few winters. We mill the surface, repair the failed seams and soft spots first, and then overlay. On some projects, we’ll add a reinforcing layer, and one pavement engineering company states that asphalt interlayer products can actually extend the life of an overlay when the surface has been cracked by frost heave. We also deal with drainage right at the seam, as an overlay will fail if water is able to get to the base.
About the Author
The Pavement Group specializes in asphalt engineering, pavement maintenance solutions, and data-driven asset management for commercial, retail, and multi-family residential properties. Utilizing advanced structural pavement evaluations and capital planning transparency, The Pavement Group works directly with property managers to extend pavement lifecycles, eliminate liability risks, and optimize long-term infrastructure investments.