Why Do Small Asphalt Cracks Turn Into Larger Problems During Winter at Apartment Communities?

Research summarized in Roads & Bridges shows that crack sealing extends pavement service life by one to nine years. The reverse is also true. A crack you ignore in October can turn into a pothole by March, whether your community sits in Minneapolis, Columbus, Boston, or Atlanta. I work with The Pavement Group, a national commercial pavement company, and we walk apartment lots every fall. This article explains why small asphalt cracks in winter grow so fast, which cracks matter most, and what you can do before the first freeze.

Water Starts the Damage

A hairline crack looks benign but, in fact, provides a route for water ingress. The same Roads & Bridges review points out that water getting into the pavement via cracks can lead to accelerated pavement deterioration and moisture damage, base failure, and potholes. A federal Long Term Pavement Performance study goes on to state that the changes in moisture content in the base of a flexible pavement are predominantly due to rainfall infiltrating through surface cracking. Once the water gets to the base, the surface is no longer supported, and the tires flex the weakened asphalt, which in turn causes the crack to widen.

Why Winter Makes It Worse

Winter adds three forces to the water problem. Firstly, water freezes in the crack and expands, then thaws and contracts again, so each cycle actually pushes the edges apart. Secondly, the crack opens and closes with the temperature so that it’s grinding the sealant or asphalt along the crack walls. The Colorado DOT has found that transverse cracks, which open and close with the temperature change, are the ones that present the most difficult challenge when it comes to crack sealing. Thirdly, grit, sand, and the like all get into the open crack. The FHWA describes crack sealing as a way of keeping water and incompressible material out of the crack and in so far as reinforcing the pavement adjacent to the crack. Once the grit has got into the crack, it stops the crack closing, and it actually wedges the edges further apart.

Apartment lots are under extra pressure. People are parking, turning, and braking in the same stalls every day, and plow blades are catching on the raised crack edges. For plow-specific damage, see how apartment communities can prevent pavement damage from snowplow operations. Joints where two paving passes meet also fail early, and we go into what causes asphalt cracking along the edges of apartment parking lot paving seams.

Know Which Crack You Have

Crack typeWhat winter does to itTypical response
Hairline surface cracksLet water seep in and freezeSeal the surface to block moisture
Transverse cracks across a drive aisleOpen and close with temperature, so they move the mostCrack sealing with a flexible hot-applied material
Longitudinal cracks and seam cracksCollect water along paving joints and lane edgesCrack filling after cleaning and drying
Alligator (interlocking) crackingPumps water to the base and often precedes potholesPatching or resurfacing, because sealing alone will not hold
Edge cracks near curbsTake water from plowed piles and runoffSeal, then fix the drainage that feeds them

How a Crack Escalates Over One Winter

StageWhat happensWhat you can do
FallA crack sits open and fills with dirt and waterClean and seal before temperatures drop
First freezeWater in the crack expandsKeep drains clear so water does not pool nearby
Repeated freeze and thawEdges chip and the crack widensFlag the spot for repair as soon as you see chipping
Plowing and trafficBlades and tires break loose piecesAsk your snow vendor to raise blades over damaged areas
Late winterA pothole opensRequest a patch, then plan a permanent repair

A Fall Walk-Through That Catches Problems Early

Every year we walk the apartment lots prior to the first freeze and record the following details. A typical walk-through takes about 30 to 45 minutes per property, depending on lot size. Ideally, the property manager should walk with the maintenance supervisor so that both management and maintenance teams can identify issues and prioritize repairs together. You can of course do the same with your own maintenance team.

  • Length, direction, and location of each crack
  • Whether the crack runs across a drive aisle and likely opens and closes
  • Cracks along curbs, drains, and dumpster pads where water collects
  • Areas where cracks connect into a web
  • Photos with a tape measure or coin for scale

How The Pavement Group Helps

The Pavement Group does asphalt paving, overlays, sealcoating, crack repair, and line striping for commercial clients all over the country. We match the repair to the crack rather than the other way around. Whether you manage one property or a full portfolio, each client receives a written survey that includes detailed site photos, a prioritized repair list, and specific recommendations for each area. Surveys are typically delivered within three business days of our site walk. The report outlines crack locations, measurements, severity ratings, and a clear map of suggested actions so you can make informed decisions and plan your budget. Ask us for references from property managers who have used us.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you seal cracks in the middle of winter?

Winter sealing generally performs worse than either fall or spring sealing. The Colorado DOT recommends sealing in the spring and fall when the cracks are open to a moderate degree. There’s research to suggest that crack sealing should follow an extended dry period so that the pavement has minimal water content. Cracks that are cold and wet won’t bond well, so we don’t seal them. If you have a dangerous crack or a pothole in the winter, you just put on a temporary patch and schedule the permanent repair for the warmer months.

How much does crack sealing cost?

Cost is dependent on crack width, length, material, and access, so a single figure is very misleading. A 2014 Indian Health Service maintenance guide listed a range of $0.90 to $18.00 per linear foot for crack filling and sealing. That’s a massive range and speaks to the variation in conditions. Today’s pricing will be different, and local labor and material costs are going to be a factor. We’ll provide you with a written quote after we’ve surveyed your property, and we’ll separate out the sealing from the patching so you can make an apples-to-apples comparison.

Should we seal cracks before or after restriping?

Seal first, then stripe. Sealant over fresh paint will smear, and paint over a fresh crack seal will tend to bond badly or discolor. We allow the sealant to set prior to laying out and spraying the lines. If a seal runs through a stall line, we’ll plan the sequence so the final line comes out clean. Doing both jobs in one visit also saves you the mobilization fee.

How do we prioritize crack repair across many apartment properties?

Start with safety, then water. We prioritize cracks adjacent to walkways, building entries, and drive aisles as they create a trip and vehicle hazard. Next are the cracks that collect or move water (cracks near drains, curbs, and low spots). We then group the properties by climate, as a property in Chicago is going to be subjected to more freeze/thaw cycles than one in Phoenix. A written survey with photos enables you to compare sites and spread the work across your budget.

When does sealing stop working and we need a patch or overlay?

Sealing works best on cracks in otherwise sound pavement. The federal Long Term Pavement Performance report found that cracks should be sealed when the wheel path fatigue cracking is less than about 6 to 7% of the pavement. That’s from highway research, so we use it as a guide rather than a rule for every lot. Once the cracks have interlocked into alligator cracks or the surface is moving under the tires, then sealing is a waste of money. At that stage we’d recommend patching, milling and overlay, or full replacement, and we go into the reasons for that in the survey report.

About the Author

The Pavement Group specializes in asphalt engineering, pavement maintenance solutions, and data-driven asset management for commercial, retail, and multi-family residential properties. Utilizing advanced structural pavement evaluations and capital planning transparency, The Pavement Group works directly with property managers to extend pavement lifecycles, eliminate liability risks, and optimize long-term infrastructure investments.

Exciting Updates You Won’t Want to Miss!

We’ve been working hard to bring you the latest enhancements, new features, and important updates. Whether it’s improvements to performance, fresh content, or exciting announcements, we’ve got something for everyone. Stay ahead and explore what’s new today!